top of page
Search
Writer's pictureAlaine Keogh

What's Better? Chicken or Beef Broth When Sick?


Mushroom soup cooked in beef broth

As the cold weather kicks in, this may be exciting for cute boots and hot chocolate season, but suddenly, everyone is coughing and blowing their noses. Welcome to cold and flu season! 


Few remedies offer comfort and nourishment as effectively as a warm bowl of broth. But you may ask the question: Should I drink chicken or beef broth when sick? 


The answer is that both of these broths can benefit us while we are sick.


Let's explore the benefits of both, unraveling the healing powers that make them go-to choices for combating illness.




Table of Contents:




Hydration: The Foundation of Healing

In the quest for recovery, hydration stands as the cornerstone. Both chicken and beef broths contribute to this essential aspect, helping the body regain lost fluids during sickness.


Maintaining proper hydration is crucial for supporting bodily functions and promoting recovery when sick. 


Both chicken and beef broths provide a soothing and hydrating base, helping to replace fluids lost through fever, sweat, and respiratory symptoms. The warm liquid aids in preventing dehydration, a common concern during illnesses.


Broth also has essential vitamins and minerals. You can think of it like an electrolyte drink without all the sugar and food coloring. 

Chicken Broth: The Healing Elixir

Chicken broth, when sick, takes the spotlight with a range of benefits that make it a go-to remedy for generations. Chicken broth, rich in vitamins, minerals, and amino acids, boasts several advantages during times of illness.

1. Immune System Boost

Chicken broth contains essential nutrients like zinc and vitamins, particularly vitamin A and vitamin C, known for their immune-boosting properties. 


These nutrients help fortify the body's defenses against viruses and bacteria, potentially shortening the duration of illness.

2. Runny Nose Relief

The steam from a soothing, hot bowl of chicken broth can help alleviate nasal congestion and soothe a runny nose. Additionally, the broth's warmth helps break down mucus, making it easier for the body to expel, providing relief from sinus discomfort. Add a little spice to your broth to help get your sinuses moving even more. 

3. Anti-Inflammatory Properties

Chicken broth contains anti-inflammatory amino acids such as glycine and proline


These compounds may help reduce inflammation in the respiratory tract, offering relief from symptoms like a sore throat or cough. The soothing effect can make the recovery process more comfortable.

4. Collagen for Joint Health

Collagen, a protein found in chicken bones and connective tissues, seeps into the broth during the cooking process. 


Chicken bone broth is made up of type II collagen. This collagen can benefit joint health, potentially easing discomfort associated with illnesses that affect the musculoskeletal system. It is also vital for healing the immune and digestive systems.

Beef Broth: A Recovery Ally

Consuming beef broth, when sick, holds its own in the realm of healing, offering unique advantages that cater to specific nutritional needs during illness.

1. Glycine in Beef Broth: A Healing Force

Glycine, an amino acid abundant in beef broth, is key in supporting various bodily functions during illness. Chicken broth also contains this amino acid, but beef broth takes the win for how much glycine it is packing.


This powerhouse amino acid possesses anti-inflammatory properties, aiding in reducing inflammation and easing some of the discomforts associated with sickness. 


In addition, glycine is a precursor to type III collagen, a vital component of connective tissues, skin, and blood vessels. Type III collagen provides structural support, contributing to the integrity of organs and tissues. 


Glycine has also been proven to improve our quality of sleep. Resting well may be difficult, but it is so important in the recovery process!


As you sip on a comforting bowl of beef broth, you're not just indulging in rich flavor – you're harnessing the healing force of glycine and type III collagen to promote tissue repair, soothe inflammation, and strengthen your body on its path to recovery.

2. Rich in Iron

Beef broth is a notable source of iron, a mineral crucial for the production of red blood cells. During illness, especially when accompanied by fatigue or anemia, the iron in beef broth can help replenish the body's iron stores and promote overall energy levels.

3. Protein Powerhouse

Protein is necessary for repairing tissues and supporting the immune system. Beef broth, derived from the simmering of bones and meat, is a protein-rich ingredient that aids the body in rebuilding and recovering during times of sickness.

4. Nutrient Absorption

The broth's nutrients are easily absorbed by the body, ensuring that it delivers a substantial amount of nutrition even in smaller quantities, and making it an excellent choice for those with reduced appetite. 

5. Bone Health Boost

The bones used to create beef broth contribute vital minerals like phosphorus and calcium to the liquid. These minerals support bone health, a factor to consider during illnesses that may impact overall bone strength.

So.. Chicken or Beef Broth When Sick?

Research shows that both have healing properties when we are sick. Both are essential for hydration and taking in nutrients for a better recovery. 


It really depends on preferences, and even a mixture of the two can be quite a blessing to your body.

What to Consider When Buying Broth

All of the listed benefits can lose their trueness when you buy the wrong kind of broth. It's essential to read labels and do research before purchasing a broth.


Here's what to steer clear of when choosing the right broth:


  • High Sodium levels

  • Fillers

  • Artificial additives

  • Monosodium glutamate (MSG)

  • Flavor enhancers

  • Added sugars


Here are some things that show you will buy a quality broth loaded with health benefits:


  • High-quality ingredients

  • Grass-fed beef or pasture-raised chicken

  • Variety of vegetables, herbs, and spices

  • Bones as the second-listed ingredient 


Following these tips will ensure bringing home a nutrient-packed broth. Working with a registered dietitian can help you learn more tips to ensure all your food purchases are causing more good than harm!

Homemade Broth: Crafting Wellness in Your Kitchen

While store-bought broths offer convenience, chicken or beef broth gains an extra edge when prepared at home. Homemade soups allow you to tailor the ingredients to your needs, ensuring a concoction of healthy elements.


Crafting your broth at home gives you control over the quality of ingredients. Fresh vegetables, herbs, and high-quality meat or bones enhance the nutritional content of the broth, maximizing its healing potential.


Store-bought broths usually contain high levels of sodium, which may not be ideal for those with certain health conditions. 


Homemade broths allow you to regulate the salt content, promoting a healthier option for individuals looking to manage their sodium intake.

Chicken and Beef Broth When Sick: A Bowlful of Comfort and Healing

The verdict may ultimately depend on personal preferences and nutritional needs in the perpetual debate of chicken or beef broth when sick. However, both variations offer healing properties during illness, providing hydration, relief from symptoms, and a nutrient-packed boost for recovery.


So, the next time you're under the weather, reach for the simmering pot and let the healing powers of chicken or beef broth work their magic when you're sick.


Nutrition education can make eating healthy feel simple! When you team up with the right nutritionist, you can feel successful in making the right choices as you stroll down the grocery aisles.


As a registered dietitian and a certified personal trainer, I offer a 1-1 weight loss coaching program designed to create a meal plan that aligns with your health objectives, whether it's weight loss, improved energy, or dietary restrictions.


7 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page